Back to top

Flat Rate Shipping is Now Available!

  • Flat rate shipping starting at $16 (view details below for all rates).
  • We ship ice cream on Tuesday's and Wednesday's ONLY.
  • Ice cream is packaged in a styrofoam shipping container with enough dry ice to keep it frozen for 24-48 hours (depending on delivery time).
  • A signature is not required; however, be sure someone will be home to receive the ice cream and get it into the freezer!
  • Within 24 hours of placing your order, you will receive an invoice, payment link, and FedEx tracking number from the Cornell Dairy. 
  • Payments must be made within 24 hours or the order will be canceled.
  • We do not include a copy of the invoice in the shipping container.
  • We anticipate your order and shipment will go smoothly and you will receive your frozen goodies within 1-2 days of the shipment date you select.  However, we also understand sometimes things go wrong.  If you have any problems with your order, Janette Robbins will be there to help you!  You can contact her through email at
  • Use the form at the bottom of this page to place your order.  Once you select the container size and quantity, you will then be able to select the flavors.


Order Options and Pricing

Container size quantity standard cost* Ice Cream Club Cost*
Pint 2 $35 Not Available
Pint 4 $59 $47
Pint 6 $78 $55
Retro Half Gallon "Alumni Swirl" 2 $50 $39
Retro Half Gallon "Alumni Swirl" 4 $85 $65
3 Gallon Tub 1 $95 $72
3 Gallon Limited Edition "We Cayenne Change the World" 1 $169 (shipping included) $169 (shipping included)

*Prices do NOT include shipping. 

Flat Rate Shipping Costs Per Order

Please note: order sizes are limited to the options listed above.  For example, we are not able to combine 6 pints and one three gallon tub into one order, that would be considered two separate orders and each would be shipped separately, incurring their own delivery cost.

States Cost per order Delivery Time
AL, CT, IL, ME, MD, MA, MO, NY, NC, PA, RI, TN, VA $16 1-2 Days
AR, DE, GA, IN, KY, MI, NH, NJ, OH, VT, WV, WI $20 1-2 Days
AZ, CA, CO, FL, IA, LA, SC, TX $45 1 Day
ID, KS, MN, MS, MT, NE, NV, NM, ND, OK, OR, SD, UT, WA, WY $52 1 Day
HI $65 1 Day
AK, PR ----- Not Available


Cornell Dairy Premium Ice Cream Order Form

Ready to place an order?  Use this form!

1 Start 2 Complete

A one-time membership fee of $55 will be added to your invoice but you will receive the membership discount and will start saving on your ice cream right away!  There is no minimum purchase required.  Within 7 days after you receive your ice cream, drop your shipping container off at any FedEx drop off location to return it to Stocking Hall (using the return label included in your shipment).  We will hold the shipping container for you until you are ready for your next order!  When you place your next order, we will  use your box to pack the new order.  Place an order as often or as little as you like, all you need to do is remember to return your shipping box for each new order.  Membership prices are applicable ONLY if you return your shipping container.  Standard pricing will be charged if you order without returning your shipping container.

Cornell Dairy Ice Cream Club membership benefits include:

  • exclusive, discount pricing for online orders
  • the opportunity to pre-order seasonal and limited edition flavors
  • an insulated Cornell Dairy tote bag
  • Cornell Dairy ice cream scoop
  • your own shipping container


Click on the button below to submit your order.  Within one business day you will receive an invoice and payment link from  If you have any questions or need to adjust your order, please use he Cornell Dairy email to contact us.

DISCLAIMER: we do our very best to keep inventory on this page up to date; however, there could come a time when a flavor you select is not available.  You will be notified ASAP and given the opportunity to adjust your order before being asked to make a payment.